Natural gas cars outselling electrics Chicago Tribune

13 Мар 2014 | Author: | Комментарии к записи Natural gas cars outselling electrics Chicago Tribune отключены
Honda Electric Cars

Advantages of natural gas cars lost in buzz for electrics

Though nearly two times as many natural gas vehicles will be on the road at year’s end than plug-ins, the federal government is investing heavily in electric technology

Peggy McGuire, uses the quick release connection to fill up her natural gas powered Honda Civic at home in LaGrange. (Tribune, Abel Uribe)

By year-end, 123,600 natural gas vehicles will be on U.S. roads, compared with 65,500 plug-in vehicles, Pike Research’s Smart Transportation practice estimates.

Some experts wonder whether the U.S. chose the wrong technology to support.

Hindsight is always 20-20, said Christopher Knittel, the William Barton Rogers Professor of Energy Economics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Sloan School of Management. The drop in natural gas prices brings up an interesting issue, which is, which technology do we want to put our money behind?

Right now, the money is behind electric vehicles, but that could change.

In February, the Obama administration proposed that the plug-in tax credit be increased to $10,000 from $7,500 and extended to other alternative fuel vehicles, including natural gas. It’s a change experts say could make natural gas-fueled cars far more price competitive. In response to demand from motorists, the Honda Civic Natural Gas car is being displayed in showrooms nationwide for the first time since it was introduced in 1998.

This month, the Department of Energy, a strong promoter of electric vehicles, awarded $30 million in research and development funding aimed at reducing the costs of making natural gas vehicles and building natural gas filling stations. Several companies, including Lisle-based Navistar Inc. have announced massive filling station buildouts along major truck routes that would be available to the public.

The interest in plug-ins traces to at least 2008, when gasoline prices seemed headed to $5 a gallon.

The following year the federal government earmarked $2 billion in Recovery Act dollars for makers of batteries and other components for plug-in vehicles and another $400 million to build a charging infrastructure. The Department of Energy pitched in with $2.4 billion in loans to Nissan, Tesla and Fisker to support plug-in manufacturing.

In addition, consumers were enticed into buying electrics with a tax credit of up to $7,500.

While there is no federal tax credit for natural gas vehicles, some states have offered incentives. In Illinois, for instance, buyers of natural gas vehicles receive a credit of up to $4,000. A Honda Civic Natural Gas is priced about $5,650 more than a gasoline-powered Civic EX.

The vehicles are less expensive than electric vehicles. The Ford Focus Electric is priced $22,700 above the gasoline version.

Natural gas vehicles just don’t have the cost challenges that electric vehicles do. You don’t need that same level of incentive, said Dave Hurst, a senior research analyst at Pike Research, which studies the electric and natural gas vehicle markets. I think the more interesting question is, why aren’t there more incentives on the infrastructure side for natural gas?

Honda Electric Cars

So far, public fueling stations for natural gas vehicles have not received the same support as charging stations, although some dollars have flowed to companies vowing to provide public access.

In some ways it’s pretty similar to the challenges we’re seeing on the electric vehicle front, Hurst said. Should infrastructure lead the vehicles, or should vehicles lead the infrastructure?

To encourage sales of its new line of natural gas-powered heavy-duty trucks, Navistar is partnering with California-based Clean Energy Fuels, which will build 150 natural gas fueling stations, all of which will be available to the public.

Pike estimates 1,358 natural gas refueling stations will be available in the U.S. by the end of the year, about half of them private. That number is about 1 percent of the 100,000 charging stations that Pike estimates will be up and running at year-end.

Why the discrepancy in stations serving electric versus gas vehicles?

Natural gas vehicle makers for years have focused on business owners and fleet operators, not average consumers, said Hurst.

Electric vehicles are more well-suited to the consumer market, he said. But when you start getting into these medium-duty and heavy-duty trucks, electric is never going to be a great solution for those. Those vehicles use a tremendous amount of fuel and (get) just a couple of miles per gallon.

In addition, natural gas filling stations, which require expensive compressors and massive highly reinforced storage tanks, are costly to build, roughly $500,000 to $1.5 million, compared with $200,000 to $400,000 for a traditional gasoline station or $50,000 for the most expensive charging stations.

The hunger for natural gas vehicles has put Honda in an enviable position. It offers the only sedan that’s sold as a natural gas vehicle.

Honda Electric Cars

Interesting articles

Other articles of the category "Honda":

Our partners
Follow us
Contact us
Our contacts


About this site

For all questions about advertising, please contact listed on the site.

Catalog ALL Electric Cars and hybrid/ News and Information about Electric Car and Electric Vehicle Technologies, batteries for vehicle catalog with specifications, pictures, ratings, reviews and discusssions about Electric and Hybrid cars - Green energy