Should Electric Cars Sound Like Traditional Cars Or Something Else?

17 Мар 2014 | Author: | Комментарии к записи Should Electric Cars Sound Like Traditional Cars Or Something Else? отключены
INFINITI M Electric Cars

Should Electric Cars Sound Like Traditional Cars, Or Something Else?

From Mother Nature Network’s Jim Motavalli:

Electric cars are quiet. Too quiet. One of the biggest virtues of the battery vehicle is that it is virtually silent in operation.

And heaven knows, in today’s marketplace, the EV needs every advantage it can get. But a quiet car can be a deadly car for the blind or disabled, and that’s led to federal government rulemaking that will require EVs to produce some kind of sound until they reach 17 mph. Exactly what those sounds will be is now being hotly debated .

I talked to Wade Newton of the Auto Alliance, which represents 12 carmakers and filed public comments last week looking to postpone the federal rule, and highly critical of the form it takes now. The alliance is walking a fine line — it supports the federal rule in principle, but doesn’t want consumers to be turned off by noisy, annoying EVs. It’s also worried about cost.

“Let the engineers figure out the best way to make it work,” Newton said. “We want a car to sound like a car, and we want some level of differentiation within a basic framework — so a sedan might sound slightly different than a coupe, for example. And if the sound is audible to the motorist, we want it to be relatively pleasing to them. But no one wants a wild west of different ringtones.”

Ah, ringtones. When I talk to people about this, they invariably get captivated by the idea of having the car produce its own personalized ringtone — a “signature” sound, so to speak. But think about it a bit: an unfamiliar ringtone conveys no recognizable message to a blind person, who’s going to hear what could be a passing car radio.

The alliance calls the ringtone thing “a Pandora’s box,” and that’s about it.

Newton also points out another big problem. “Any sound the car produces will be heard very differently in Times Square and a rural road in upstate New York,” he said. So do you optimize the sound for loud environments or quiet ones?

The automakers also want the sound to cut off at 12.4 mph, not 18.6, because they say above that speed tire noise makes the car audible anyway. The federal rule is supposed to begin phasing in September of 2014, but the carmakers want to forget phasing it in and delay implementation to 2018.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) estimates the cost at $30 to $35 per car, but the alliance says it’s way higher. The safety agency says it’s a vital matter of, well, safety. “NHTSA estimates that if this proposal were implemented, there would be 2,800 fewer pedestrian and pedalcyclist injuries over the life of each model year of hybrid cars, trucks and vans and low-speed vehicles, as compared to vehicles without sound,” the agency said.

The National Federation of the Blind is highly supportive of the legislation and was instrumental in shaping it. “Quiet vehicles are highly problematic for blind pedestrians, who depend on the sound emitted by cars in order to travel safely and independently. “We feel strongly that the industry must take measures to insure the safety of blind and sighted pedestrians,” NFB says. “We believe that vehicles can be designed to emit an inoffensive sound that will give pedestrians the information they need.”

Loading Slideshow

Nissan ‘Cima’

Japan’s auto giant Nissan Motor executive vice president Hiroto Saikawa (L) displays the company’s new luxury sedan ‘Cima’, which has the new hybrid system with V6-3.5 litter gasoline engine and electric motor to achieve 364-horsepower high performance and good economy efficency of 16.6km per litter at the company’s headquarters in Yokohama, suburban Tokyo on April 25, 2012. Nissan will put it on the market from May. YOSHIKAZU TSUNO/AFP/Getty Images

Lexus RX 450h Hybrid SUV

Japan’s auto giant Toyota Motor managing officer Kazuo Ohara (R) introduces the company’s newly designed Lexus RX 450h hybrid SUV with a 3.5-litre V6 engine in Tokyo on April 12, 2012. Toyota will put it on the market on April 21. YOSHIKAZU TSUNO/AFP/Getty Images

Fisker Karma

A Fisker Karma hybrid car is displayed at the US carmaker’s booth on March 6, 2012 during a press day ahead of the 82nd Geneva Motor Show in Geneva. Some 700 carmakers will be taking part in the Geneva Motor Show, which opens to the public from March 8 to 18. FABRICE COFFRINI/AFP/Getty Images

Hyundai Sonata Hybrid

The Hyundai Sonata hybrid car on display February 2, 2012 at the 2012 Washington Auto Show at the Walter E. Washington Convention Center in Washington, DC. The auto show runs through February 5. KAREN BLEIER/AFP/Getty Images

Toyota Prius C Hybrid

The Toyota Prius C hybrid is introduced during a press preview at the North American International Auto Show at the COBO Center January 10, 2012 in Detroit, Michigan. The NAIAS opens to the public January 14th and continues through January 22nd. (Photo by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images)

Mercedes F 125 Concept Fuel Cell Hybrid

A Mercedes F 125 Concept fuel cell hybrid car is on display at the international motor show IAA (Internationale Automobil-Ausstellung) in Frankfurt/M, western Germany, on September 14, 2011. The world’s biggest motor show, the IAA, is running on display at the international motor show IAA (Internationale Automobil-Ausstellung) in Frankfurt/M, western Germany, on September 14, 2011. The world’s biggest motor show, the IAA, is running from September 15 to 25, 2011. PATRIK STOLLARZ/AFP/Getty Images

BMW i8 Plug-In Hybrid All-Electric

LOS ANGELES, CA — NOVEMBER 17: The BMW i8 plug-in hybrid all-electric concept car makes its North American debut at the Los Angeles Auto Show on November 17, 2011 in Los Angeles, California. The car show opens to the public tomorrow and runs through November 27. (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)

Volkswagen SUV ‘Cross Coupe’

Models show off the concept SUV ‘Cross Coupe’ of German’s Volkswagen, which is the all-whell-drive plug-in hybrid vehicle, during the Tokyo Motor Show in Tokyo on November 30, 2011. TORU YAMANAKA/AFP/Getty Images

Toyota ‘Aqua’

Journalists check Japanese auto giant Toyota Motor’s new compact hybrid car ‘Aqua’, equipped with a 1.5-litter gasoline engine and an electric motor to drive the five-seater body in Tokyo on December 26, 2011. The world’s highest efficiency vehicle, which achieved 35.4km/litter for fuel efficiency, started to sell here. YOSHIKAZU TSUNO/AFP/Getty Images

Peugeot Citroen RC Hybrid

People look at a RC hybrid car by French car maker PSA Peugeot Citroen on December 14, 2011 at the Peugeot store on the Champs Elysees avenue in Paris. PSA will experience a ‘significant loss’ for the second half of the year said the president of the board Philippe Varin during a hearing at the National Assembly in Paris on December 14, 2011. LIONEL BONAVENTURE/AFP/Getty Images

Toyota Camry Hybrid

Japan’s auto giant Toyota Motor unveils the new ‘Camry’ hybrid sedan, equipped with a 2.5-litre engine with an electric motor hybrid system, during a press preview in Tokyo on September 5, 2011. Toyota started selling the mid-sized flagship sedan from September 5. YOSHIKAZU TSUNO/AFP/Getty Images

Toyota ‘Prius A’

A cameraman takes video of the new ‘Prius a’ (alpha) minivan-style hybrid vehicles by Japan’s auto maker Toyota Motor in Tokyo on May 13, 2011. Toyota annouced the launch of the seven-seat model equipped with a lithium-ion rechargeable battery, with the five-seat model equipped with a nickel metal hydride battery in Japan. TORU YAMANAKA/AFP/Getty Images

The Porsche 911 GT3 R Hybrid

The Porsche 911 GT3 R Hybrid Facebook Race Car during the 2011 New York International Auto Show at the Jacob Javits Convention Center in New York April 21,2011. TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/Getty Images

Chevy Volt Hybrid

DETROIT- NOVEMBER 30: A General Motors Chevrolet Volt goes through assembly after GM celebrated the official launch of the Chevrolet Volt hybrid electric vehicle at GM’s Detroit-Hamtramck Assembly November 30, 2010 in Detroit, Michigan. The Volt extended-range electric vehicle, for which 1,000 jobs will be created by General Motors over the next two years, started production earlier this month. (Photo by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images)

BMW ActiveE

The hybrid car ‘BMW ActiveE’ is presented at a plant of German carmaker BMW in Leipzig, eastern Germany, 05 November 2010. BMW are expanding its Leipzig plant for the production of the newly-developed Megacity Vehicle, a zero-emission car featuring an extremly light plastic bod, and is to be produced in Leipzig from 2013. AFP PHOTO / POOL / PETER ENDIG (Photo credit should read PETER ENDIG/AFP/Getty Images)

Honda ‘Fit Hybrid’

Japan’s auto maker Honda Motor president Takanobu Ito introduces the company’s new hybrid compact car ‘Fit Hybrid’, equipped with 1.3-litre electric motor and front-wheel drive during a preview at the company’s headquarters in Tokyo on October 8, 2010. Honda started selling the vehicle on the Japanese market and will export to Europe as the ‘Jazz Hybrid’. YOSHIKAZU TSUNO/AFP/Getty Images

Interesting articles

Other articles of the category "Interesting":

Our partners
Follow us
Contact us
Our contacts


About this site

For all questions about advertising, please contact listed on the site.

Catalog ALL Electric Cars and hybrid/ News and Information about Electric Car and Electric Vehicle Technologies, batteries for vehicle catalog with specifications, pictures, ratings, reviews and discusssions about Electric and Hybrid cars - Green energy